Blog categories

My blog posts and tweets are my own, and do not necessarily represent the views of my current employer, my previous employers or any other party.

Many of these blogs were originally posted elsewhere on public sites, but have been re-posted here with attributions to the original location -- strictly as a means of a centralized archive of my perspectives.

I do not do paid endorsements, so if I am appear to be a fan of something, it is based on my personal experience with it. If I am not talking about your stuff, it is either because I haven't worked with it enough or because my mom taught me "if you can't say something nice ... "

Need Help with WinSvr 2012 Storage Spaces

Howdy MS friends,

I used to be a fan of Windows Server 2012’s Storage Spaces:

And for those that don’t know, I used to work at MS … on Windows storage features.  But I am totally stuck – and needing help.

Two of my five drives in a Storage Space failed.  So, like I would do with any other storage rack, I unplugged them and put in two identical HDD’s.  Technically, if this was a hardware array, I might have hot-swapped them, but I did power-down and then power up.

RESOLUTION ATTEMPT 1 — I added them to my set and voila!  The two new drives added themselves to the total capacity WITHOUT replacing the drives that had failed.  UGGH!

RESOLUTION ATTEMPT 2 — After searching the Internet (because the documentation wasn’t prescriptively clear), I found out that I should have added those drives as “HotSpare” and that Windows would figure out to replace it.  So, I added another exactly the same drive as a hot-spare watched as nothing happened.

RESOLUTION ATTEMPT 3 – So I rebooted, thinking maybe that would wake up the repair process.   And now, the management UI shows six drives in use … and the two failed drives still there.

Here’s a screenshot:


I can’t click “Remove Disk” on the failed drives … because it says that I need to add new drives of equal capacity, blah blah.

I can’t click “Remove Disk” on the newly added empty drives (so that I can retry again) … because it says that they are part of the active set with volumes on them.

I can’t click “Repair Drive” on the virtual disks … because it says that the resources can’t be found.


Leave a Reply

@JBuff on Twitter